No Longer Nomads

Process
Overview
No Longer Nomads is a podcast hosted by Josh Doyle about faith, the supernatural and people whose lives changed when they met Jesus: former psychics, ex-Muslims, people who went looking for answers in witchcraft, the occult and secret societies. The show started out focused on men and parenting. By 2026 its strongest episodes were about the unseen world, and the audience for those stories was on YouTube and Spotify.
We started working with Josh in late May 2026 on growth: strategy, packaging, ads on YouTube and Spotify, email, design and the launch of Wanderers After Dark, a storytelling series for the show's Patreon.
The Challenge
On paper the YouTube channel was growing fast. It went from about 19,000 subscribers in November 2025 to 45,000 by July 2026. Most of that growth came from subscriber campaigns the team had been running in-house.
Our audit in May showed what those campaigns were buying. Paid ads accounted for 88.8% of the subscribers the channel had gained and 42.6% of its views. People who arrived through the ads watched for 45 seconds on average. People who found the show on their own watched for 12 minutes and 46 seconds. We estimated that about half of the ad-driven subscribers were bots.
From March to mid-July the channel gained about 9 new subscribers for every 100 views, a rate no engaged audience produces. By August, with 45,000 subscribers, a typical upload was getting between 85 and 950 views, and the only big episodes were guest crossovers that brought their own audience. On Spotify, weekly plays had been flat for three months.
Those subscribers did nothing for new uploads. YouTube recommends each video to the viewers most likely to watch it, and subscribers who never watch count for very little. The ad budget had bought a bigger number and very few viewers.
Our Approach
- Stop buying empty subscribers. We paused the in-house subscriber campaigns and let the count settle. Subscriber growth stopped in mid-July, and the total slipped as YouTube cleared out accounts that weren't real. We let that happen on purpose. A smaller audience that watches is worth more than a bigger one that doesn't.
- Lead with the stories people are looking for. Episodes about parenting and family were getting a few hundred views. The supernatural, spiritual warfare and real encounters were finding new viewers on their own. We built the show's packaging around what was already working.
- Rebuild titles, thumbnails and descriptions. Using our podcast packaging and discovery process, we rewrote titles as clear statements of the story. In our tests, statement titles drew more than twice the click-through of question titles. We rewrote descriptions for search on YouTube, Spotify and Apple, and started repackaging the back catalog with new thumbnails in one consistent style.
- Targeted ads on YouTube and Spotify. New YouTube campaigns each promote one episode to people already interested in its topic, from UFOs and the Nephilim to New Age practices and AI, and are judged on whether viewers keep watching and come back for more. On Spotify, we started a campaign in mid-September to reach new listeners.
- A Short almost every day. The channel had been posting about three Shorts a month. We set up a clipping workflow that turns each episode into a run of Shorts, each opening on the guest's strongest claim.
- Shows in the same space. Josh's conversations with Ninjas Are Butterflies, Blurry Creatures and BLK SHP Bible Talk introduced the show to established audiences who already love this kind of story.
- Somewhere for new listeners to go. We launched Wanderers After Dark on Patreon with a free first episode on the main channels, so the people the show reaches have a deeper way to follow it.

Results
YouTube started recommending the show. In early October, ads brought in about half of the channel's YouTube views. By early November, YouTube's own recommendations brought about two-thirds, and ads were under 20%. Viewers who find the show through recommendations watch for about 16 minutes on average.
A breakout on both platforms. Episode 108, "The Ancient Gods Never Left?" with BLK SHP Bible Talk, reached 113,000 YouTube views in its first nine days, with an 18-minute average view, 246 comments and 747 new subscribers. On Spotify it tied the show's all-time high for first-week plays. It has since passed 139,000 views on YouTube.
About four times the YouTube views. The channel gained 21,500 views in June and 164,000 in October, about four times as many after adjusting for YouTube's August 27 change to how views are counted. In August the channel lost 300 subscribers as fake accounts cleared out. In October it gained 1,000.
The audio audience grew too. Weekly Spotify plays had been flat all summer. After the Spotify campaign started in mid-September, they more than doubled, reaching 865 in the last week of October. From June to October:
- Spotify listeners per day rose 76%, from 30 to 53
- Listening hours per day grew 2.5 times, from 21.4 to 53.9
- New Spotify followers per month grew 4.8 times, from 37 to 178
- Returning listeners per day rose 68%, from 25 to 42
Better packaging gets more clicks. Older episodes with new thumbnails now get 5.4% to 6.7% click-through, above the channel average of 4.7%.
Ongoing partnership: growth strategy, ads, packaging and the Wanderers After Dark Patreon continue as the show heads into 2027.


